diner is a category all its own, characterized by qualities like frequent water and coffee refills, small packets of jelly and sugar on the table, filet of sole on the menu, etc. a diner could be the worst in the world but still score a 10 on diner. while diner is arguably the most important quality, all four categories are weighterd the same in the final score.
Midnight Express (Yorkville)....................................................... 8
ambience......................8
price............................8
food............................7
diner............................9
The Mansion Diner (Yorkville).......................................................... 6
ambience...........................7
price.................................3
food..................................8
diner.................................6
Skylight Diner (Hudson Yards)........................................................ 6
ambience.........................8
price............................7
food............................5
diner............................8
Gracie Mews Diner (Yorkville)..................................................... 5.25
ambience........................6
price.............................4
food...............................5
diner............................6
Coopertown Diner (Gramercy Park)................. 8
ambience..................8
price.......................7
food.......................8
diner.......................9
Remedy Diner (Lower East Side)................. 6.5
ambience.................5
price.......................8
food.......................5
diner.......................8
Joe Junior (Gramercy Park)........................ 6.5
ambience.................8
price.......................6
food.......................3
diner.......................9
Orion Diner (Gramercy Park)...................... 6.25
ambience..................5
price.......................7
food.......................6
diner.......................7
Kellogg's Diner (Williamsburg)..................... 5.5
ambience.................9
price.......................7
food.......................5
diner.......................2
Nautilus Diner (Mamaroneck, NY)............................................................................................................................................. 7.5
ambience........................7
price.............................7
food...............................6
diner............................10
BLD Diner (Larchmont, NY).......................................................................................................................................................7.5
ambience.....................................................7
price..............................................8
food.....................................................7
diner.....................................................8
Historic Village Diner (Red Hook, NY)....................................................................................................................................7.25
ambience........................7
price.............................9
food...............................6
diner............................7
Parkway Cafe (Scarsdale, NY).............................................................................................................................................7.25
ambience..............................6
price.................................8
food.............................6
diner....................................................9
Sip N' Soda (Southampton, NY)..............................................................................................................................................5.5
ambience.............................4
price.............................7
food.............................5
diner.............................6
Edgartown Diner (Edgartown, MA)..............................................................................................................................................7.25
ambience........................8
price.............................7
food...............................6
diner............................8
Courtesy Diner (St. Louis, MO).............................................................................................................................................6.25
ambience........................3
price.............................9
food...............................7
diner............................6